blog

TL;DR

• Its Strength was its rigor and its commitment to preserving high technical and intellectual standards.*
• Its Weakness was that this rigor calcified into dogma and conformity, resisting innovation and personal expression.*

The Bad

Conformity

The academic system was built on a specific set of rules for creating "good" art. This included:

• Idealization over Realism: Figures should be perfect and idealized, not as they appear in real life (with flaws, blemishes or ordinary bodies). This was based on classical Greek and Roman art.
• Formal Composition: Scenes had to be carefully constructed, often in a triangular or pyramidal arrangement, to create a sense of balance and order.
• Conservative Color and Finish: Colors were often muted and subordinate to the drawing. The finish was expected to be smooth and polished, with no visible brushstrokes, creating an almost porcelain-like surface. This stifled creativity and personal expression. An artist's individual style or a new way of seeing was considered a fault, not a virtue.

Rigid Hierarchy of Subjects (The Genre Hierarchy)

The Académie established a strict ranking for subject matter, which dictated an artist's prestige and success.

1. History Painting At the top. Included religious, mythological, historical and allegorical scenes. These were considered the most intellectual, requiring knowledge of literature, history and the Bible.
2. Portraiture
3. Genre Painting Scenes of everyday life.
4. Landscape
5. Still Life At the very bottom. Considered mere copying without intellectual depth. This devalued artistic subjects that people could connect with in their daily lives (like landscapes or still lifes) and forced artists to work on "important" but often remote and idealized themes.

Lack of Innovation and Originality

Academicism was associated with a strict adherence to traditional techniques and styles, which limited the possibilities for innovation and originality. The Académie believed that the artistic ideals of the Renaissance and Classical antiquity had reached a peak that should be emulated, not surpassed. This created a culture of:

• Elitism: Art was made for and judged by, a small, wealthy and educated elite who understood the complex references and approved of the conservative values.
• Exclusivity: The institutions of art and education were often exclusive and elitist, which limited access to artists from lower social classes and backgrounds.
• Rejection of the Contemporary: It ignored the social, industrial and scientific revolutions of the 19th century. While the world was changing rapidly, the Académie was still promoting paintings of Roman gods and Greek heroes. This made art irrelevant to the modern experience and the growing middle class. It was seen as backward-looking and out of touch.

The Salon and Gatekeeping

The annual Salon de Paris was the only significant venue for artists to exhibit and build a reputation. A jury of Academicians decided what was shown.

• Arbitrary Rejection: The jury was notoriously conservative, routinely rejecting works that deviated from their standards in style, subject or technique.
• The Salon des Refusés: The situation became so dire that in 1863, Emperor Napoleon III had to authorize a separate exhibition for the thousands of artists rejected from the official Salon — the famous "Salon of the Rejected." This was where Manet's Déjeuner sur l'herbe was first shown, causing a scandal. This prevented new ideas from reaching the public and crushed the careers of non-conformist artists.

The "Factory" Model of Art Production

To succeed, artists often had to:

• Produce repetitive, crowd-pleasing works.
• Rely on wealthy patrons who demanded specific, conservative subjects.
• Work with a team of assistants (especially for large history paintings). This reduced art to a commodity and undermined the Romantic ideal of the artist as a solitary, inspired genius.

Lack of relevance

Academicism was often seen as being out of touch with the changing needs and values of society and was criticized for being irrelevant and outdated.

The Good

Technical Mastery

Academic artists were known for their exceptional technical skill, which they developed through rigorous training and practice. Their work was characterized by precise draftsmanship, detailed rendering and a mastery of various mediums, such as oil painting, sculpture and printmaking.

• Drawing (*Disegno): The foundation of all academic training was life drawing. Students spent countless hours drawing from plaster casts of classical sculptures and live models. This resulted in an ability to render the human form accurately and expressively.
• Complex Composition: Academic artists were masters of arranging multiple figures in a large, coherent scene. They knew how to guide the viewer's eye, create drama and build a narrative through posture, gesture and placement.
• Mastery of Media: Techniques like glazing in oil painting to achieve rich, deep colors and subtle transitions were passed down and perfected within this system.

Intellectual and Narrative Depth

By placing History Painting at the top of its hierarchy, Academicism insisted that art be more than just a pretty picture; it should be a vehicle for ideas.

• Elevated Subject Matter: Artists engaged with the great stories of the Bible, mythology and history. To be a successful academic painter, you had to be well-read and able to translate complex narratives and allegories into visual form.
• Moral and Civic Lessons: These paintings were often intended to inspire virtue, patriotism and reflection. They were seen as a way to educate the public and elevate public taste by connecting them to a shared cultural heritage.

Preservation of Cultural Heritage

• Connection to the Past: By venerating the classics and the Renaissance, they maintained a continuous link to the artistic achievements of the past. Artists like Raphael, Poussin and the sculptors of antiquity were constant reference points.
• A Standard of Quality: While this standard became restrictive, it provided a clear, shared framework for what constituted "good" art. This created a common language that patrons, critics and the public could understand.

Realism and representation

Academic artists were known for their commitment to realism and representation. They believed in depicting the world as it was, without distortion or exaggeration. This emphasis on realism was seen as a way to create a sense of truth and authenticity in their work.

Social and cultural significance

Academicism was seen as a way to promote social and cultural values. Artists were expected to create work that was considered respectable, tasteful and suitable for public viewing. This emphasis on social and cultural significance was seen as a way to create a sense of civic duty and responsibility among artists.

Institutional support and patronage

The academic system provided a clear career path for Artists

• Structured Training: The progression from drawing casts, to life drawing, to full paintings was a logical and thorough way to learn.
• System of Patronage and Recognition: Winning prizes like the prestigious Prix de Rome provided funding, prestige and state commissions. The annual Salon was the primary platform for an artist to achieve fame and secure patrons. Academicism was closely tied to the institutions of art and education, such as the Académie des Beaux-Arts in Paris. The Académie and other institutions provided artists with a sense of stability, support and patronage, which allowed them to focus on their craft and to produce high-quality work.

Production of Great Art

Many works created within the Academic system are masterpieces by any measure.

TL;DR

A major upside of oil painting is that its long history gives it an aura of professionalism that other media do not have. That can increase the perceived value of a painting. However, the toxicity and clean up aspects are too much of a concern for me to go this route.

The Bad

Long Drying Time

This is the most famous characteristic and its biggest double-edged sword.

• Slow Workflow: A layer of oil paint can take days, weeks or even months to dry completely. This makes it difficult to work quickly, create multiple paintings in a short time or make quick corrections.
• Vulnerability: Wet paintings are vulnerable to dust, pet hair and accidental smudging, requiring careful storage while they dry.

Toxicity and Fumes

This is the most serious health concern.

• Solvents: Traditional solvents like turpentine and mineral spirits are used for cleaning brushes and thinning paint. Their fumes are toxic, can cause dizziness, headaches and long-term exposure is linked to organ damage. They are also highly flammable.
• Pigments: Some pigments themselves are toxic (e.g., those containing lead, cadmium or cobalt). Inhaling dust from sanding a dry painting or getting paint on your skin can be hazardous.
• Ventilation is a Must: You cannot safely use these materials in a small, unventilated room. This makes it impractical for many home studios.
• Note: Many artists now use odorless mineral spirits (OMS) for solvents and wear gloves, but caution is still required.

Complexity and Learning Curve

Oil painting has a steep learning curve due to its "fat over lean" rule.

• Fat Over Lean: Each subsequent layer of paint must contain more oil than the one beneath it. If you don't follow this rule, the painting can crack, peel, or not dry properly over time.
• Technical Knowledge: Understanding mediums, drying times and layering techniques requires more initial study compared to more straightforward paints like acrylics.

Cost and Materials

Oil painting is generally more expensive than other forms of painting.

• Paints: High-quality artist-grade oil paints are significantly more expensive than student-grade acrylics or watercolors.
• Brushes and Surfaces: While you can use many of the same brushes, you also need to invest in solvents, mediums, proper palettes and prepared surfaces (canvas, wood panels) that are primed for oil.
• Ongoing Costs: Solvents and mediums need to be replenished regularly.

Cleanup and Maintenance

The cleanup process is more involved and messier.

• Messy Cleanup: You can't just rinse brushes in water. They require scrubbing with soap and water after being cleaned in solvent.
• Disposal: You can't pour used solvent down the drain. It needs to be disposed of properly as hazardous waste, often by letting the paint particles settle and decanting the clear solvent for reuse.

Practical Inconveniences

• Space: You need a dedicated, well-ventilated space that can be left undisturbed for long periods.
• Portability: It's not an easy "plein air" (outdoor) painting medium unless you are well-prepared with a portable easel and safe containers for solvents.
• Curing Time: Even when a painting is dry to the touch, it can take 6 months to a year to fully "cure" before it can be safely varnished.

The Good

Unparalleled Blendability and Workability

This is arguably the greatest advantage of oil paint.

• Slow Drying Time: Unlike the drawback for some, this is a huge benefit for the painting process. The paint stays wet and workable for days, allowing you to blend colors directly on the canvas. The long, open working time allows for a more contemplative and flexible process. You can step back, think about your composition for hours or even days and then re-enter the painting to make changes without the paint skinning over.
  • Wet-on-Wet & Layering: You can work alla prima (all at once, wet-on-wet) for expressive pieces, or use the classic layered approach (fat over lean) for highly detailed and durable works.
  • Easy Corrections: Mistakes can be easily wiped away with a rag and solvent while the paint is wet, or scraped down and painted over once dry.
• Seamless Gradients: You can create incredibly soft, smooth transitions between colors and tones — perfect for realistic skin, skies and subtle shadows. This is much harder to achieve with fast-drying acrylics.
• Rich, Luminous Color and Depth Oil paints are famous for their color quality.
• High Pigment Load: They are rich in pigment, producing intense, vibrant colors.
• Translucency and Glazing: Oil paint can be thinned to transparent glazes. By layering these glazes, light passes through and reflects off the lower layers, creating a depth and luminosity that is difficult to replicate with opaque paints. It’s the same principle as stained glass.
• Buttery Consistency: The thick, buttery texture holds brushstrokes and palette knife marks perfectly, adding a physical, textural depth to the work.
• Versatility and Range of Effects You can achieve almost any look with oils.
• Range from Thin to Thick: You can use it thin and fluid for washes (like watercolor) or thick and textural for impasto techniques (like buttery acrylics, but with more body).
• Control Over Finish: By using different mediums, you can make the paint matte, satin or glossy.
• Textural and Three-Dimensional Qualities
  • Impasto: The thick consistency of oil paint is perfect for building up textured, expressive surfaces that catch the light and add a physical presence to the artwork. This texture is often more pronounced and buttery than what can be achieved with acrylics.

Durability and Longevity

A properly executed oil painting is incredibly durable.

• Proven Track Record: We have oil paintings from the Renaissance that are still vibrant and intact today. The paint film is flexible and strong as it ages.
• Resistant to Yellowing: Unlike some acrylic varnishes, modern synthetic oil painting varnishes are non-yellowing and can be removed for cleaning without affecting the paint layer.

TL;DR

For me the risk that a mistake could destroy an almost finished painting overrides the potential beauty of this medium.

The Bad

• Lack of Control: Unlike acrylics or oils, watercolor is driven by the water. It flows, bleeds and does what it wants. Achieving sharp, precise details requires immense skill and planning.
• Difficult to Correct Mistakes: There is no undo in watercolor. Once a dark value is laid down or a color bleeds where it shouldn't, it's difficult to fix. Lifting paint with water or a sponge can work, but it often leaves a "ghost" of the original stain and can damage the paper surface.
• Mud, Mud, Mud: Overworking the painting (going over an area too many times) causes colors to mix directly on the paper instead of optically. This often results in dull, muddy and murky colors instead of clean, vibrant ones.
• Timing is Everything: Watercolor has distinct "stages" (wet, damp, dry). The effects you get depend entirely on the wetness of the paper and brush. Miss that perfect moment of dampness for a soft blend and you're left with a hard, unintended edge.
• Expensive, High-Quality Materials are a Must:
  • Paper is King: You cannot use just any paper. Cheap, thin paper will buckle, pill, and not allow for proper lifting or layering. 100% cotton paper is the gold standard and is significantly more expensive.
  • Pigment Quality: Student-grade paints often use fillers and less pigment, making colors appear chalky and less vibrant. Professional paints are a major investment.
• The Buckling Paper Problem: Even with good paper, applying a lot of water (a "wash") will cause the paper to buckle and warp as it dries. This requires stretching the paper beforehand (a tedious process) or using a block, which is more expensive.
• Preserving Whites: Unlike other mediums where you add white paint at the end, in watercolor, you must plan to save the white of the paper from the very beginning. This requires thinking in negative space and can be mentally taxing. Using masking fluid can help but is messy and can tear the paper if not removed carefully.
• Opacity and Layering Limitations: Watercolor is inherently transparent. It's very difficult to paint a light color over a dark one. This means you must work from light to dark, which is a reverse way of thinking for many artists. There is no covering up a mistake with a fresh layer of paint.
• Not Ideal for All Subjects: Its fluid, ethereal nature makes it less suited for subjects that require high detail, heavy texture or many opaque corrections (no to photorealistic portraits or impasto-style landscapes).
• Long Drying Times: While faster than oils, you still have to wait for a layer to dry completely before applying the next one in order to avoid colors bleeding into each other. This can slow down the painting process.
• A Steep Learning Curve: The gap between what a beginner envisions and what appears on the paper is often vast and discouraging. It requires patience and a willingness to embrace "happy accidents" rather than fight them.
• Fragility of Finished Work: Watercolor paintings are more vulnerable. They can fade if not framed under UV-protective glass, and they are susceptible to water damage if they get wet again.

The Good

Unique and Unpredictable Aesthetic

This is arguably the biggest draw. Watercolor has a life of its own.

• Luminosity and Transparency: Unlike opaque paints like acrylic or oil, watercolor is transparent. The white of the paper shines through the pigments, creating a glowing, light-filled effect that is almost impossible to replicate with other mediums.
• Fluidity and Flow: The way colors blend and bleed into each other on wet paper creates soft edges, beautiful gradients and "happy accidents" that can be magical.
• The "Bloom" Effect: When a drop of wet paint or clean water is added to a damp wash, it creates organic, feathery shapes called "blooms" or "cauliflowers." These are often seen as flaws by beginners but are cherished by experienced artists for their textural beauty.

Practical and Accessible Nature

• Portability and Quick Setup: A basic watercolor kit is incredibly compact. A small palette, a couple of brushes, a water bottle and a pad of paper are all you need. You can paint outdoors (en plein air), on your lunch break, or while traveling with minimal fuss. There's no need for solvents, palette knives or extensive cleanup.
• Fast Drying Time: Watercolor dries very quickly. This allows you to work rapidly, build up layers in a single session and easily correct mistakes (by rewetting and lifting paint) without waiting days for a layer to dry.
• Relatively Low Cost to Start: While professional-grade materials can be expensive, you can get a good beginner's set-up for a reasonable price, making it one of the most accessible art forms.

Challenging yet Rewarding Process

Watercolor is often called "the master medium" because it teaches you patience and planning.

• Teaches You to Let Go: Its unpredictable nature forces you to embrace imperfection and chance. You learn to work with the medium rather than trying to control it completely. This can be an excellent lesson in mindfulness and acceptance.
• Forward Planning and Patience: Since it's difficult to cover up mistakes with opaque paint, you must think in reverse — painting from light to dark and reserving the white of the paper for your brightest highlights. This teaches strategic thinking and patience.
• A Sense of Achievement: Mastering a difficult technique, like a perfect graded wash or a controlled wet-on-wet application, brings a tremendous sense of accomplishment.
• Mindfulness: Mixing colors, watching the paint flow across the paper and focusing on the brushstrokes pulls you into the present moment. It’s a form of active meditation that can reduce stress and anxiety.
• Connection to the Elemental: There's a primal, simple pleasure in working with just pigment, water and paper. It feels direct and elemental.
• A Break from Perfectionism: Because it's so fluid, watercolor naturally resists hyper-realism and tight control. It encourages a more loose, expressive and interpretive style, which can be a liberating break for people who feel pressured to be perfect.

Styles

It can be used for loose, impressionistic sketches, highly detailed botanical illustrations, vibrant urban sketches and even bold, graphic works.

Techniques

You can achieve a range of effects:

• Wet-on-Wet: For soft, dreamy blends.
• Wet-on-Dry: For sharp edges and detail.
• Dry Brush: For textured, scratchy effects.
• Lifting: To correct mistakes or create highlights.
• Layering (Glazing): To build depth and complexity of color.